LightNode Logo

VDI vs RDP vs RDS: Which Remote Desktop Solution Is Right for Your Business?

LightNode
By LightNode ·

VDI vs RDP vs RDS: Which Remote Desktop Solution Is Right for Your Business?

As remote work and cloud-hosted applications become standard, many organizations rely on remote access technologies to keep teams productive. Among the most common solutions are VDI, RDP, and RDS—each offering different levels of flexibility, performance, isolation, and scalability.

If you're exploring or deploying an RDS server, or simply comparing the three options, this guide explains how they work, what makes them different, and which one fits your business needs.

What Is VDI?

VDI (Virtual Desktop Infrastructure) delivers full virtual desktops running on centralized servers. Each user receives an individual virtual machine, offering the highest level of isolation and customization.

How VDI Works

  • Each user is assigned a fully independent virtual desktop (Windows or Linux).
  • Desktops run on a centralized server cluster or cloud platform.
  • Users connect through a thin client or remote access application.

Benefits of VDI

  • Strong user isolation
  • High security and centralized updates
  • Customizable environments
  • Ideal for GPU workloads, design applications, and development

Limitations of VDI

  • Higher infrastructure and licensing costs
  • Complex setup and maintenance
  • Requires strong storage and networking performance

Best For

  • Enterprises
  • Graphics-intensive workloads
  • Development or finance teams
  • Environments requiring strict data separation

What Is RDP?

RDP (Remote Desktop Protocol) is Microsoft’s protocol that allows users to connect remotely to individual desktops or servers.

How RDP Works

  • A user connects to a specific physical or virtual machine.
  • The server transmits screen output to the client and receives keyboard/mouse input.
  • Ideal for single-user access.

Benefits of RDP

  • Built into Windows
  • Easy to configure
  • Excellent for remote server administration
  • Low-cost remote access option

Limitations of RDP

  • Not ideal for multi-user environments
  • Performance limited by the host machine
  • Requires security hardening for internet-facing access

Best For

  • Small teams
  • IT administrators
  • Individual remote workers
  • Remote troubleshooting

What Is RDS?

RDS (Remote Desktop Services) is Microsoft’s platform for delivering multi-user desktops and applications from a central RDS server.

It is built on top of RDP but designed for multiple concurrent users.

How RDS Works

  • Multiple users log into a shared Windows Server session.
  • Applications are hosted centrally and accessed remotely.
  • Licensing requires RDS CALs (Client Access Licenses).

Benefits of RDS

  • Supports many users on a single server
  • Lower cost per user compared to VDI
  • Centralized application and desktop delivery
  • Ideal for call centers, training teams, and office tools

Limitations of RDS

  • Less isolation—users share the same OS
  • Some applications do not support multi-session mode
  • Requires proper capacity planning and load balancing

Best For

  • Growing businesses
  • Teams with similar workflows
  • Centralized application hosting
  • Cost-efficient remote access

VDI vs RDP vs RDS: Key Differences

Feature VDI RDP RDS
User Isolation High Medium Low–Medium
Cost Highest Lowest Medium
Scalability High Low High
Setup Complexity High Low Medium
Best For Full desktops, GPU workloads Remote PC access Multi-user environments
Performance Needs High Low Medium
Management Centralized per-VM Individual machines Centralized server

Quick Summary

  • VDI → Best security, highest cost, full desktop per user
  • RDP → Simple and cheap remote access to a single PC/server
  • RDS → Multi-user remote desktop platform with excellent cost efficiency

How to Choose the Right Solution

Choose VDI if:

  • You need isolated desktops
  • You run heavy or GPU-based applications
  • Security is a top priority
  • Budget allows higher infrastructure investment

Choose RDP if:

  • You only need to access individual PCs or servers
  • Your team is small
  • You want the simplest remote access method

Choose RDS if:

  • You need centralized multi-user access
  • Your workloads fit a shared server environment
  • You want a cost-effective remote desktop platform

Best Practices for Deploying an RDS Server

1. Plan Server Capacity

Consider:

  • Number of concurrent users
  • 2–4 GB RAM per user
  • Proper CPU allocation
  • NVMe/SSD storage to prevent bottlenecks

2. Secure Your RDS Environment

  • Enforce strong password policies
  • Limit IP access via firewall
  • Enable TLS/SSL
  • Use an RD Gateway when exposing to the internet

3. Enhance User Experience

  • Use FSLogix for profile management
  • Optimize session host performance
  • Enable graphics acceleration if available

4. Monitor and Scale Efficiently

  • Track CPU, RAM, disk queue length, and sessions
  • Implement load balancing for large deployments
  • Cloud providers make horizontal scaling easy

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

1. Is RDS the same as RDP?

No. RDP is a protocol for remote connection, while RDS is a multi-user platform built on RDP. RDS manages multiple users on a single server.

2. Can VDI replace RDS?

VDI can replace RDS in environments needing strong isolation, but it is more expensive. Many businesses use both to balance cost and security.

3. How many users can an RDS server support?

Typical ranges:

  • 4 vCPU + 16GB RAM → 10–20 users
  • 8 vCPU + 32GB RAM → 25–40 users
    The actual limit depends on workload type.

4. Is RDP secure for remote access?

Not directly. For safe access, use:

  • VPN
  • RD Gateway
  • IP restrictions
  • Strong passwords + MFA

5. What’s the main advantage of RDS?

RDS allows many users to share one server, reducing cost per user while maintaining centralized administration and consistent performance.

Back to the list